non-compete clause

To Compete or Not to Compete: Enforceability of Non-Compete Agreements in Texas

In a typical non-compete clause or covenant not to compete an employee agrees that at the end of his or her employment they will not work for or start a similar business in competition with their former employer. The restrictive nature of non-compete agreements have long been debated. Indeed, most states, including Texas, have enacted legislation to address the limited situations where such restraint of competition is allowed.

Ancillary to An Otherwise Enforceable Agreement

First, to be enforceable in Texas a non-compete agreement must be “ancillary to an otherwise enforceable agreement.”

This requirement basically means that both parties to the agreement made binding promises. Although it sounds simple, what constitutes ancillary to an otherwise enforceable agreement has been the subject of much litigation. 

An At-Will Employee Can Be Subject to a Non-Compete Clause

Historically, Texas at-will employees challenged non-compete agreements. They argued that since they could be fired at any time, any promises made by the employer were illusory. In 2006, however, the Texas Supreme Court held that an at-will employee could be subject to a non-compete once the consideration was provided by the employer. For example, once an employer provided specialized training or provided trade secrets, the non-compete clause could be potentially binding regardless of an at-will employee status.

“Reasonably Related” to the Need to Restrain Competition

Prior to 2011, Texas courts also held that the consideration provided to an employee must “give rise” to the need for an employee to restrain competition. The Texas Supreme Court changed the standard in Marsh USA, Inc. v. Cook. The consideration now has to be “reasonably related” to the need to restrain competition. Consideration such as confidential information, trade secrets, and the need to protect goodwill could, in the right case, meet this standard.

Reasonable Restrictions on Time, Geography and Activities

If the non-compete is ancillary to an otherwise enforceable agreement, then Texas courts evaluate the reasonableness of the restrictions imposed. Specifically, courts look to the restrictions on time, geographical location and activity. What constitutes reasonable time, geographical and activity restraints is fact based and determined by the courts. Courts typically evaluate on a case by case basis.

Nevertheless, some general guidelines have emerged from Texas case law. For example, geographical restrictions beyond the area where the employee performed work on behalf of the employer are generally found to be unreasonable. With regard to the activity restrained, non-competes that restrict contact with clients or customers that the employee had no contact with are typically considered unreasonable. On the other hand, the analysis may be complicated by the size of the company and the nature of the industry involved. 

Similarly, with regard to the amount of time an employee is restricted, the analysis is more complex. In these cases, courts consider the industry involved, the role of the employee within the company and other factors.

Employers and Employees Need to Know Texas Non-Compete Law

Both employers and employees are often faced with the question, “is my non-compete agreement enforceable?”. Rogge Dunn Group has vast experience analyzing and evaluating non-compete agreements in Texas and across the country. Our employment lawyers regularly obtain and defend against temporary restraining orders and preliminary injunctions regarding non-compete agreements. If you have questions about a non-compete agreement contact us here.

MEDIA

Texas Payday Law: The Final Paycheck
READ MORE
Jan. 15, 2021: Rogge Dunn to Speak at the Texas Bar’s 29th Annual Advanced Employment Law Seminar on How to Win an Employment Case at Trial
READ MORE
Executive Change of Control Provisions
READ MORE
To Compete or Not to Compete: Enforceability of Non-Compete Agreements in Texas
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Weighs in on Whataburger Discrimination Complaint on Fox 4 News
READ MORE
Employee Rights in Texas
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group, PC Receives “2020 Texas Legal Awards Litigation Department of the Year – Small Firm” Award by Texas Lawyer
READ MORE
The Role of the Plaintiff’s Employment Lawyer Before a Lawsuit
READ MORE
The Texas Lawbook Interviews Rogge Dunn on Wage and Hour Litigation Increases
READ MORE
Dec. 1, 2020: Rogge Dunn to Speak in LIVE CLE Webcast on Demystifying the Current Landscape of Broker-Dealers Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic: What You Must Know and Do
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group Attorneys Nationally Recognized in Best Lawyers in America 2021 Edition
READ MORE
The Real Estate Investor Guide to Finder’s Fees – Insight from a Real Estate Lawyer
READ MORE
COVID-19 Continues to Create Employment Issues
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Interviewed by AdvisorHub on Multi-Million Comp Award to Former Credit Suisse Brokers
READ MORE
How a FINRA Compliance Lawyer Can Help
READ MORE
CoStar News Interviews Rogge Dunn on Pandemic-Related Layoffs
READ MORE

Contact Us Today!

Contact us to learn how we can help answer your legal questions.

FILL OUT FORM