Reptilian Plagiarism: CSI Sues Rival DecisionQuest

© 2016 The Texas Lawbookhttps://texaslawbook.net/

By Mark Curriden

csilogo100

(Nov. 28) – A heated battle between the nation’s two largest litigation consulting businesses has made its way into federal court in Dallas, again.

Courtroom Sciences, a Las Colinas-based jury selection firm started by TV psychologist Dr. Phil McGraw in 1990, accuses rival DecisionQuest of plagiarizing a CSI copyrighted, analytical report that debunks one of the most popular trial strategies used by plaintiff’s lawyers in big-dollar cases.

The lawsuit claims that CSI Vice President Bill Kanasky Jr. authored two lengthy articles in 2014 about a courtroom technique called the “Reptile Theory,” which shifted the age-old strategy of plaintiff’s lawyers from trying to make jurors sympathetic for their clients to instead make them angry about the conduct of corporate defendants.

In the complaint filed in the Northern District of Texas, CSI lawyers claim that DecisionQuest Vice President Ann Greely of Houston presented a paper at an American Bar Association Litigation Section meeting in New Orleans in May 2015 adopting much of Kanasky’s analysis and many of his conclusions” but doing so “without crediting” Kanasky.

“It is obvious that Greeley did not do independent and substantial research on her own,” the lawsuit states. “Even worse, Greeley violated copyright laws by copying parts of [Kanasky’s] article word for word.

“This is not merely a case of similar writings that might constitute copyright infringement,” Dallas lawyer Rogge Dunn, who represents CSI, states in the lawsuit. “This is a case blatant and intentional plagiarism where numerous words, phrases and entire sentences were copied.”

Dunn points to one specific paragraph in the DecisionQuest document in which 90 of the 108 words are exactly the same as those from the CSI paper.

“This is not case of copying for educational use or for purely academic purposes,” Dunn states in the complaint. “This infringement was designed for commercial gain.”

The DecisionQuest document, which is posted on the ABA’s website, does include the paragraph that appears to be copied from the CSI document without direct attribution.

But a review of the DecisionQuest document by The Texas Lawbook, also shows that Greeley cited Kanasky four times in the article and three more times in the list of references.

DecisionQuest officials did not respond to a request for comment.

MEDIA

Employee Rights in Texas
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group, PC Receives “2020 Texas Legal Awards Litigation Department of the Year – Small Firm” Award by Texas Lawyer
READ MORE
The Role of the Plaintiff’s Employment Lawyer Before a Lawsuit
READ MORE
The Texas Lawbook Interviews Rogge Dunn on Wage and Hour Litigation Increases
READ MORE
Dec. 1, 2020: Rogge Dunn to Speak in LIVE CLE Webcast on Demystifying the Current Landscape of Broker-Dealers Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic: What You Must Know and Do
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group Attorneys Nationally Recognized in Best Lawyers in America 2021 Edition
READ MORE
The Real Estate Investor Guide to Finder’s Fees – Insight from a Real Estate Lawyer
READ MORE
COVID-19 Continues to Create Employment Issues
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Interviewed by AdvisorHub on Multi-Million Comp Award to Former Credit Suisse Brokers
READ MORE
How a FINRA Compliance Lawyer Can Help
READ MORE
CoStar News Interviews Rogge Dunn on Pandemic-Related Layoffs
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group Represents Ex-CFO Allegedly Fired for Whistleblowing
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Interviewed on WFAA Regarding COVID-19 in the Workplace
READ MORE
Aug. 20, 2020: Rogge Dunn to Speak in Live CLE Webcast on How To Manage and Resolve Complex Commercial Disputes
READ MORE
Big Changes for Title IX: New Title IX Requirements
READ MORE
Fired for Following the Law? Wrongful Termination Cases During COVID-19
READ MORE

Contact Us Today!

Contact us to learn how we can help answer your legal questions.

FILL OUT FORM