shareholder dispute lawyer

The Role of the Business Judgment Rule in Shareholder Disputes

What is the Business Judgment Rule?

Corporate directors owe fiduciary duties to the corporation. The Business Judgment Rule (BJR) is the legal presumption that corporate directors using their business judgment have acted, or are acting, within their fiduciary duties unless there is evidence of fraud, bad faith, or gross disregard of their responsibilities. The concept is based on the principle that directors of a corporation are motivated in their conduct by a bona fide regard for the interests of the corporation. In other words, the BJR assumes that directors are trying to do the right thing for the corporation. 

State Laws Concerning the Business Judgement Rule

Most states have some version of the BJR for evaluating director decisions. Given that Delaware is home to most major U.S. corporations, a number of states follow Delaware precedent. It serves as a good framework for BJR inquiries but does not necessarily reflect the law in every state.

Practical Application of the BJR

If a filed lawsuit relates to a shareholder dispute involving director decisions, the BJR often functions as a “front end” legal protection. This is routinely used to ask for an early dismissal of director defendants. Since the presumption is that the directors acted in good faith, plaintiffs bear the burden of rebutting the presumption in order to survive a motion to dismiss. Although the underlying notion of the BJR presumes that directors are making decisions in the best interests of the company, that isn’t always the case (i.e. cases of self-dealing).

Shareholder Dispute Lawyers and BJR

To combat potential allegations that a director’s actions fall outside the scope of the BJR presumption, it is a good business practice to document business decisions. These documents should show that the director:

(1) Acted in good faith,

(2) On a fully informed basis, and

(3) Can justify how he/she expects the ultimate outcome to be beneficial to the company. This is especially important when the short-term impact is not necessarily beneficial.

In the event of a filed lawsuit, a shareholder dispute lawyer can help determine which BJR analysis is applicable. This depends on the location of the business’s incorporation. A shareholder dispute lawyer can also assess the actions of the director. Finally, this lawyer can evaluate whether they fall within the protections of the BJR.

Questions About a Shareholder Dispute?

Rogge Dunn Group has shareholder dispute lawyers familiar with the wide range of potential, and often complex, litigation. The Firm’s plaintiff clients include minority shareholders (both individuals and groups) and limited partners. Oftentimes, they assert claims based on minority shareholder oppression and breach of fiduciary duty against majority owners in control of corporate entities and partnerships. The Firm also represents and protects the rights of majority and controlling shareholders, corporate officers, directors, managers, and general partners against claims by those holding minority interests and other issues inherent in a “business divorce.”

For more information, contact the Rogge Dunn Group here.

MEDIA

Rogge Dunn Quoted in Financial Advisor on Credit Suisse Mishandling Discharge
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in Dallas Morning News Article Following Roe V. Wade Being Overturned
READ MORE
Employee Discrimination in the Workplace
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in Yahoo Article on Tesla Racial Bias Case
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in AdvisorHub Article on Stephens, Inc Arbitration Case
READ MORE
RDG WINS JURY VERDICT AND ATTORNEYS’ FEE AWARD ($1.9M) FOR CEO CLIENT
READ MORE
Bullying in the Workplace
READ MORE
Unfair Pay and Compensation in the MLB
READ MORE
Trans Athletes
READ MORE
Reverse Racism in the Workplace
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in Dallas Morning News Article on Testing Unvaccinated Employees Under New Vaccine Mandate
READ MORE
Sex Discrimination at Work
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in WFAA Article on Texas Universities Vaccine Requirements
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in D Magazine Article on Conflicting Vaccines Rules
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in FOX4 Article About Southwest Airlines Employees Protesting the Vaccine Mandate
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Quoted in Law360 Article About Employers Heeding Vaccine Mandate Ban
READ MORE

Contact Us Today!

Contact us to learn how we can help answer your legal questions.

FILL OUT FORM