Making the Switch to Arbitration: Texas Supreme Court Finds Party Invoked Litigation Process

The Texas Supreme Court recently ruled that once a party has substantially invoked the litigation process, the party cannot switch to arbitration shortly before trial. While a strong presumption against waiver of arbitration rights exists, the presumption can be rebutted with evidence that the party seeking arbitration substantially invoked the litigation process, prejudicing another party.

In Perry Homes v. Cull, __ S.W.3d __ (Tex. May 2, 2008), a homebuilder challenged whether homeowners seeking damages from the homebuilder and two warranty companies for faulty construction could switch to arbitration after pursuing the case in court for over a year. The Court found that whether a party has so substantially invoked the litigation process as to waive its right to arbitration requires a case-by-case determination. Because the homeowners sought extensive discovery, vigorously opposed arbitration when other parties raised the issue, and moved for arbitration late in the trial process (four days before a trial setting), the Court found that the homeowners had substantially invoked the litigation process. The Court further found that the homeowners’ conduct prejudiced the homebuilder and the warranty companies. Thus, the homeowners waived their right to seek arbitration.

For more information on arbitration policies and procedures, please contact the Dallas arbitration lawyers at Rogge Dunn Group at info@roggedunngroup.com.

Media Information:

Address: 500 N. Akard St., Suite 1900, Dallas, TX 75201
Phone: 214-888-5000
Url: Rogge Dunn Group

MEDIA

Why Wall Street’s biggest wealth managers could face an avalanche of lawsuits thanks to one judge’s ruling
READ MORE
FDA Concedes COVID Shots Trigger Baby Seizures, Re-Recommends Them Anyway
READ MORE
Executive Travel: Deer Valley in Park City, Utah
READ MORE
The Importance Of Giving Back To Community: What Drives Rogge Dunn Group To Improve And Provide Professional Services
READ MORE
LOANDEPOT, CARDINAL SUED OVER ALLEGED DECEPTIVE PRACTICES
READ MORE
HONORING OUR NATION’S HEROES
READ MORE
The Importance of Being Earnest
READ MORE
KEY INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENTS IN MARCH
READ MORE
Social Media Scrutiny Continue Education Testing Tip and More
READ MORE
Several Developments in January are of Interest to Financial Advisors
READ MORE
Rogge’s Roundup: Several developments in January are of interest to financial advisors — February 16, 2023
READ MORE
Rogge’s Roundup: Social Media Scrutiny, Continuing Education Testing Tip and more – March 15, 2023
READ MORE
Rogge’s Roundup – Key Industry Developments in March
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group Relaxes, Ramps Up Team Building During Cancun Weekend
READ MORE
$1.75 million settlement finalized in lawsuit against Collin DA, top county officials
READ MORE
Stifel’s Raiding Suit Against RIA Adds to Pile of High-Stakes Claims
READ MORE

Contact Us Today!

Contact us to learn how we can help answer your legal questions.

FILL OUT FORM