Texas Supreme Court Rules on Premises Liability Case

On April 18, 2008, the Texas Supreme Court ruled on a premises liability case. The Texas Supreme Court found that a premises owner was not liable for a student’s injury sustained when he tripped over over a water hose lying across a campus sidewalk. The reasoning was that there was no evidence of the University’s actual knowledge that a water hose lying across a sidewalk was an unreasonably dangerous condition.

In University of Texas-Pan American v. Aguilar, — S.W.3d —, 2008 WL 1765553 (Tex.), 51 Tex. Sup. Ct. J. 795 (4/18/08), Tony Aguilar – – a student at the University of Texas-Pan American – – was walking to class when he tripped on a water hose lying across a campus sidewalk and broke his knee. The student and his wife sued the University to recover damages alleging premises liability. The University filed a plea to the jurisdiction, arguing that the plaintiffs failed to plead facts sufficient to establish a waiver of governmental immunity under the Texas Tort Claims Act. The trial court denied the motion, and the University appealed.

The court of appeals concluded the University’s safety manual was sufficient to create a fact issue about whether the University had actual knowledge that the water hose presented an unreasonable risk of harm, and affirmed the trial court’s decision.

The Texas Supreme Court reversed, and dismissed the plaintiffs’ case. In so doing, the Court recognized that a unit of state government (such as the University) has a duty under the Texas Tort Claims Act either to warn a licensee of, or make reasonably safe, a dangerous condition of which the governmental unit has actual knowledge and the licensee does not. It also found that, although there is not one test in a premises liability case to determine actual knowledge that a condition presents an unreasonable risk of harm, Texas courts generally consider whether the premises owner has received reports of prior injuries or reports of the potential danger presented by the condition.

However, it held that the University’s workplace safety manual – – which warned of the dangers of obstructing office walkways with exposed electrical cords – – was not evidence of the University’s actual knowledge that a water hose lying across a sidewalk was an unreasonably dangerous condition. Therefore, it did not constitute the actual knowledge necessary to give rise to a duty under Texas Tort Claims Act to either warn the student who was injured or to make the condition reasonably safe.

If you would like a copy of this opinion, or more information on the topic, please contact the personal injury lawyers at Rogge Dunn Group at info@roggedunngroup.com.

Media Information:

Address: 500 N. Akard St., Suite 1900, Dallas, TX 75201
Phone: 214-888-5000
URL: Rogge Dunn Group

MEDIA

Rogge Dunn Weighs in on Whataburger Discrimination Complaint on Fox 4 News
READ MORE
Employee Rights in Texas
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group, PC Receives “2020 Texas Legal Awards Litigation Department of the Year – Small Firm” Award by Texas Lawyer
READ MORE
The Role of the Plaintiff’s Employment Lawyer Before a Lawsuit
READ MORE
The Texas Lawbook Interviews Rogge Dunn on Wage and Hour Litigation Increases
READ MORE
Dec. 1, 2020: Rogge Dunn to Speak in LIVE CLE Webcast on Demystifying the Current Landscape of Broker-Dealers Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic: What You Must Know and Do
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group Attorneys Nationally Recognized in Best Lawyers in America 2021 Edition
READ MORE
The Real Estate Investor Guide to Finder’s Fees – Insight from a Real Estate Lawyer
READ MORE
COVID-19 Continues to Create Employment Issues
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Interviewed by AdvisorHub on Multi-Million Comp Award to Former Credit Suisse Brokers
READ MORE
How a FINRA Compliance Lawyer Can Help
READ MORE
CoStar News Interviews Rogge Dunn on Pandemic-Related Layoffs
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Group Represents Ex-CFO Allegedly Fired for Whistleblowing
READ MORE
Rogge Dunn Interviewed on WFAA Regarding COVID-19 in the Workplace
READ MORE
Aug. 20, 2020: Rogge Dunn to Speak in Live CLE Webcast on How To Manage and Resolve Complex Commercial Disputes
READ MORE
Big Changes for Title IX: New Title IX Requirements
READ MORE

Contact Us Today!

Contact us to learn how we can help answer your legal questions.

FILL OUT FORM